UK Tribunal Rules Anti-Zionism Is a Legally Protected Belief After Professor’s Unfair Dismissal Case

A UK employment tribunal has ruled that Professor David Miller was unlawfully dismissed by the University of Bristol over his criticism of Zionism, confirming that anti-Zionism can be recognised as a legally protected philosophical belief under British law.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal stated that Miller’s dismissal in 2021 followed comments expressing beliefs protected under equality legislation. The tribunal found that the university’s decision amounted to unlawful discrimination and ruled that his dismissal was both unfair and wrongful.

Miller, a former professor of political sociology at the University of Bristol, welcomed the ruling, describing it as a victory for people in Britain who oppose Zionism. He said the decision would make it more difficult for employers to punish individuals simply for holding anti-Zionist views.

The case began after Miller challenged his dismissal, arguing that he was unfairly removed from his position and discriminated against because of his beliefs. In an earlier ruling, the tribunal found that his comments were lawful, did not constitute anti-Semitism, and did not encourage violence or threaten public safety.

The University of Bristol said it was disappointed with the judgment but reaffirmed its commitment to protecting free speech while ensuring that expressions remain within its codes of conduct.

Miller said the case had contributed to a climate of self-censorship among academics but expressed hope that the ruling would encourage more scholars to openly debate Zionism and issues related to the Middle East.

• Tweet
• Share
• Share
• Share
• Share