China has expressed reluctance to participate in a proposed nuclear arms control agreement involving the United States and Russia, citing the significant difference between its nuclear capabilities and those of the two major powers.
The issue is expected to feature prominently during a planned trilateral meeting involving US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, China.
Trump is pushing for a new nuclear arms agreement that would bring all three countries under a common framework following the expiration of the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New START) in February 2026.
The previous agreement, signed in 2010 by the United States and Russia, restricted the number of deployed strategic nuclear warheads to 1,550 for each country. It also introduced limits on long-range missiles and bombers, alongside provisions for inspections of nuclear facilities.
However, the treaty expired after its five-year extension ended, bringing an end to decades of agreements aimed at controlling the nuclear arsenals of Washington and Moscow.
Why Does Trump Want China Included?
The Trump administration believes that a new nuclear arms agreement would be incomplete without China's participation, given the country's rapidly expanding nuclear weapons programme.
US officials argue that limiting nuclear weapons between Washington and Moscow alone would no longer reflect the changing global security environment.
Washington also wants a new agreement to cover additional nuclear weapons systems and emerging military technologies that were not adequately addressed under the previous treaty.
Why Is China Opposed to the Proposal?
China's main concern is the imbalance between its nuclear arsenal and those of the United States and Russia.
According to estimates from the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI), China possesses approximately 620 nuclear warheads, compared with more than 5,000 each held by the United States and Russia.
Although China's nuclear stockpile is considerably smaller, its arsenal is reportedly expanding faster than those of other nuclear powers, with approximately 100 additional warheads developed annually since 2023.
Beijing maintains that it should not be expected to accept the same restrictions as countries with significantly larger nuclear arsenals.
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian previously stated that China's nuclear capabilities were not comparable to those of Washington and Moscow, adding that Beijing was not prepared to participate in nuclear disarmament negotiations at this stage.
Security experts say China is also concerned that an agreement could restrict its ability to strengthen its nuclear deterrence while leaving other military advantages enjoyed by the United States untouched.
These include missile defence systems, advanced conventional weapons and precision-strike capabilities.
China has consistently maintained that its nuclear weapons policy is based on minimum deterrence and a commitment not to use nuclear weapons first.
Could the Three Countries Reach an Agreement?
Security analysts believe an agreement involving the three nuclear powers remains possible, but significant differences must first be addressed.
China is reportedly more interested in a gradual approach that would involve discussions on strategic stability, nuclear doctrines, military transparency and communication during international crises.
Experts have also suggested that Washington and Moscow should first make substantial reductions to their nuclear arsenals before expecting Beijing to accept similar restrictions.
Any future agreement would likely need to recognise the different military capabilities, security concerns and nuclear strategies of the three countries.
Analysts further argue that negotiations should address missile defence systems, artificial intelligence in nuclear operations and other emerging military technologies.
Political Tensions Could Delay Negotiations
Despite growing international interest in nuclear arms control, political tensions between the three countries could make meaningful progress difficult.
The ongoing Russia-Ukraine war, disagreements over Taiwan and growing US-China military competition in the Asia-Pacific region remain major obstacles.
Experts believe that informal agreements and diplomatic discussions are more likely in the short term than a comprehensive nuclear arms treaty.
For now, China's reluctance to join the proposed agreement highlights the growing challenge of achieving global nuclear disarmament at a time when major powers are increasingly focused on strengthening their military capabilities.
Tags
World News
